[TexasARDF] 1:10000 vs. 1:150000

[Matthew Robbins]

My question back to you would be: What scale is usually used at
Bastrop?  A lot of times the map is made for one or the other scale.
There is a convention that the 1:10000 printed map is supposed to be a
pure 150% print of the 1:15000 map, but that's often not the case,
especially for older maps.

If there is a lot of detail, 1:10000 is really nice.

Another thought is that maps usually have border information, like a
title, legend, copyright, mapper, revision dates, etc.  Any
experienced competitor can just cut away the entire border and leave
only the actual map.  I'd propose that a 1:10000 map only, no title,
legend, etc, should preferably fit on 8.5x11.  If that overly
constrains your course, then the two options are (1) jump to 1:15000,
or (2) tell everyone how big the mapboard needs to be at 1:10000.
(Typically a map of the border only is posted, with the map itself cut
out).

Matthew
Cincinnati

On Jan 26, 2008 12:53 PM, Kenneth E. Harker <kenharker at kenharker.com> wrote:
>      The organizing committee for the 2008 USA ARDF Championships is having
> an internal debate about the map scale to use for the competition.  We would
> like to have the maps fit on an 8.5" x 11" sheet of paper.
>
> 1:15000: Same scale as used in World Championships.  We can probably get
>          slightly longer courses on the maps, but that might involve slight
>          overlap in terrain from day 1 to day 2.
>
> 1:10000: Easier to read, including some terrain detail (principally dry
>          ditch markings) that tend to get lost at 1:150000.  Courses would
>          necessarily be shorter in order to fit entirely on the map - some
>          classes would probably have an optimal course length < 6 km.
>
>      I would like to get a sense of what everyone would prefer.  In 2006
> in North Carolina we used 1:15000.  In 2007 in California we used 1:10000.
>
> --
> Kenneth E. Harker WM5R
> kenharker at kenharker.com
> http://www.kenharker.com/
>
> _______________________________________________
> TexasARDF mailing list
> TexasARDF at lists.texasardf.org
> http://lists.texasardf.org/mailman/listinfo/texasardf
>